Ambulatory surgery center vs Outpatient hospital

Topics:

  • Understanding ASCs
  • What is an ambulatory surgery center
  • Understanding Outpatient Hospitals
  • Differences in Services Offered
  • Comparing Cost-Effectiveness for Patients and Providers
  • Quality of Care and Patient Outcomes
  • Similarities between ASCs and Outpatient Hospitals
  • Differences between ASCs and Outpatient Hospitals
  • Innovations and Technological Advancements

Although often misconstrued as being interchangeable, an ambulatory surgery center (ASC) and an outpatient hospital are separate entities within the medical healthcare space. The differences between the two become essential when considering a medical practice from the level of a physician, especially when at the fundamental level of insurance. Subtle in nature, the differences between ASCs and outpatient hospitals can produce impactful, auspicious results when unpacked.

What is the Ambulatory Surgery Center

To begin, Ambulatory Surgery Centers (ASCs) are medical entities that provide outpatient surgical care on a diagnostic and preventive procedures level without the headaches that often accompany receiving such procedures at an inpatient hospital.

These centers offer patients several advantages over traditional hospital-based surgical procedures, including shorter wait times, lower costs, and smaller chances of infectious disease exposure.

ASCs offer several advantages over traditional hospital settings:

  • Cost-effective: ASCs have lower overhead costs than hospitals, which can result in significant savings for patients and insurance companies.
  • Convenient: Patients typically arrive at the ASC on the day of their surgery and are discharged home within a few hours. This eliminates the need for an overnight stay and allows them to recover in their home.
  • Less stressful environment: ASCs are designed to be more patient-centered than hospitals. They are typically smaller and less crowded, and the staff is dedicated to providing personalized care and attention.
  • High-quality care: ASCs are required to meet strict safety and quality standards. They are also subject to regular inspections by state and federal agencies.

What are Outpatient Hospitals?

Outpatient hospitals are healthcare facilities where patients receive medical care without requiring an overnight stay. This means they visit the hospital for diagnosis, treatment, or procedures but are able to return home the same day. This differs from inpatient hospitals, where patients are admitted and stay overnight or longer for more intensive care.

Outpatient hospitals offer a wide range of services, including:

  • Diagnostic services: Lab tests, imaging scans like X-rays or MRIs, and other tests to assess health conditions.
  • Treatment services: Minor surgeries, outpatient procedures like colonoscopies, infusions, injections, and other therapies.
  • Specialty clinics: Cardiovascular care, oncology (cancer treatment), mental health services, and others.
  • Rehabilitation services: Physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech therapy.
  • Emergency room services: For urgent medical needs that don’t require hospitalization.

Differences in Services Offered

Understanding the services offered by Ambulatory Surgery Centers (ASCs) compared to those provided in Outpatient Hospital departments is crucial for physicians and healthcare professionals guiding their patients toward the most appropriate venue for surgical care.

At its core, an ASC is tailored for surgeries that don’t require an overnight hospital stay. You’ll find that a wide range of procedures, particularly those considered less complex—such as cataract surgery, endoscopies, minor orthopedic operations, and certain plastic surgeries—are staples of the ASC environment. These centers are designed for efficiency and speed, which means patients are often able to walk in, undergo a procedure, and return home the same day.

On the flip side, Outpatient Hospital departments can handle a broader scope of procedures, including some that may be more complex or require more extensive post-operative monitoring that can extend into the evening but still does not necessitate an overnight stay. Procedures such as advanced laparoscopic surgeries, some cardioversions, and certain biopsies are typically within the service range of an Outpatient Hospital.

It is relevant to note that while ASCs are thriving in specialization, offering targeted services with surgical teams performing specific types of surgeries regularly, Outpatient Hospitals often have the advantage when it comes to a multidisciplinary approach. They can provide patients with immediate access to a wider range of specialists and more comprehensive care if unexpected complications arise during or after a procedure.

While both ASCs and Outpatient Hospitals maintain strict patient care and safety standards, the main distinction lies in the types of services deemed suitable for each setting. This choice will depend on the complexity of the procedure, the anticipated need for post-operative care, and the patient’s risk profile.

Improve patient engagement with Ambula

Create a rememberable patient experience and more patients through your practice.

Comparing Cost-Effectiveness for Patients and Providers

In terms of direct costs, procedures performed in an ASC can be approximately 45-60% less expensive than the same procedures performed in a hospital outpatient setting. This is significant when it comes to healthcare budgets and patient billing. Insurance co-pays and surgery deductibles can also be substantially lower for procedures completed in an ASC, positioning these centers as a financially savvy choice for eligible patients.

For providers, the streamlined operations of ASCs may translate to a more focused and potentially more profitable business model. With ASCs typically serving patients who have been prescreened for complicating medical conditions, they can provide quality care without the resources required to manage higher-risk patients. This leads to decreased variable costs per patient and can result in increased efficiency of the surgical teams due to reduced procedure variability.

Still, it’s not just about the immediate billing. The financial benefits for patients also include shorter wait times and faster discharges, which can translate to reduced time off work or away from other responsibilities—a non-monetary factor worth considering when discussing cost-effectiveness.

ASCs and outpatient hospital facilities leverage economies of scale but differently. ASCs often standardize equipment and supplies, reducing unit costs. They can negotiate bulk pricing for implants or other high-expense items due to certain surgeries’ high volume and repeatability.

Quality of Care and Patient Outcomes

Studies have consistently shown that ASCs offer comparable or superior success rates and complication rates compared to outpatient hospitals for a wide range of surgical procedures. For instance, a 2019 study published in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery found that patients undergoing total hip arthroplasty (THA) in ASCs had similar complication rates and functional outcomes as those who underwent THA in outpatient hospitals. Similarly, a 2020 study published in JAMA Surgery reported that patients undergoing cataract surgery in ASCs had lower rates of postoperative complications compared to those who underwent cataract surgery in outpatient hospitals.

Patient satisfaction metrics and experiences

Patient satisfaction with care is consistently higher in ASCs compared to outpatient hospitals. Surveys have shown that patients appreciate the more personalized care, shorter wait times, and more comfortable environment of ASCs. For example, a 2021 study published in the Ambulatory Surgery Journal found that patients undergoing colonoscopy in ASCs were significantly more satisfied with their care than those in outpatient hospitals.

While both care environments are committed to positive patient outcomes, as a healthcare professional, you need to delve into the specifics of each patient’s case. The patient’s overall health, the complexity of the surgery required, and their support system at home play considerable roles in determining the most appropriate setting for surgical care.

Similarities between an Ambulatory Surgery Center and Outpatient Hospitals

Ambulatory care is sometimes called outpatient care. Outpatient hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers both offer outpatient procedures, the likes of which can be surgical, preventative, and diagnostic in nature, such as endoscopies or colonoscopies. Like a hospital operating room, ASCs contain nurses and doctors abiding by firm guidelines and procedures. Their duty is to make sure patients are safe, in a sterile environment and ensure successful operations.

Although it is important to keep in mind that all surgical operations have risks, there are no additional ones involved in outpatient procedures when compared to in-hospital treatments. Besides these similarities in procedures, staff, and safety guidelines, the parallels between ASCs and outpatient hospitals are not quite as significant as their differences.

Differences between an Ambulatory Surgery Center and Outpatient Hospitals 

One of the main differences between an ambulatory surgery center and an outpatient hospital is who runs the facility. Because the surgical center in an outpatient hospital is owned and run by a hospital, it is subject to its specific structural system, rules, and regulations. An ASC, on the other hand, is a free-standing practice that may have a different structure from other medical practices. This structural difference often results in ASCs costing patients less than a hospital would.

And although the highest quality of practice and safety are present in both ambulatory surgical centers and outpatient hospitals, studies have found that ASCs notably have fewer post-surgery complications due to the lessened risk for contagion exposures.

Moreover, ASCs are often more specialized in specific procedures, resulting in better operation outcomes than hospitals that attempt to cover various specialties in one building and risk cross-contamination.

When it comes to outpatient surgical procedures, ASCs are notably a safer and more cost-effective alternative to procedures performed in a hospital setting.

Innovations and Technological Advancements

You’re working in an era where technological advancements transform surgical care, and staying abreast of these changes is paramount. Ambulatory Surgery Centers (ASCs) often lead the way in adopting new technologies, particularly those that promote minimally invasive procedures. This means shorter patient recovery times and the ability to perform more surgeries.

In Outpatient Hospitals, you might find a broader array of advanced tech due to larger budgets and diverse patient needs. Robotics and high-definition diagnostic imaging are common, supporting more complex procedures. These technologies improve precision and can lead to better outcomes, but they come with a cost that’s often reflected in patient billing.

One significant technological differentiation is the use of electronic health records (EHRs). It’s become clear that integrating EHR systems in ASC centers improves patient safety and streamlines care. Both ASCs and Outpatient Hospitals are increasing their adoption rates, but the level of integration can vary significantly.

Have any more questions? Feel free to call the Ambula Healthcare team at (818) 308-4108! And now, do you know who can own a surgery center?

What are the key components of physician practice management emr system

Keep up to date with the latest in healthcare and technology!

Subscribe to Ambula’s weekly newsletter – don’t get left behind!