An electronic medical record should support the work of a practice—not make essential tasks harder, hide important information, or leave the organization uncertain about its data and continuity. During a product evaluation, look beyond a polished demo and watch for red flags in realistic workflows.
Eight EMR red flags to look for
1. Common tasks require awkward workarounds
If routine documentation, medication review, results, or referrals require duplicate entry or confusing navigation, the system may add friction and increase the chance of missed steps. A product should not force every specialty or team into the same workflow without room for appropriate configuration.
Test it: ask users from different roles to complete representative tasks, including an exception, and describe what feels unclear or repetitive.
2. Important information is difficult to find or verify
A crowded screen, unclear dates or sources, duplicate notes, or a medication list with no visible review status can make it difficult to know what is current. A system should help users distinguish new information from historical or imported content.
Test it: ask a clinician to locate a recent result, identify its source and date, and confirm whether it has been reviewed and acted on.
3. Alerts are noisy, unexplained, or impossible to tune
Alerts can support attention, but a high volume of low-value messages can interrupt work and make important warnings easier to overlook. A demo should show how alerts are configured, why they appear, and how the organization reviews their usefulness.
Test it: ask the vendor to demonstrate several clinically relevant scenarios and explain what the user sees, what action is recorded, and how alert performance can be monitored.
4. Data export and transition plans are vague
A practice should understand how it can retrieve its records if it changes vendors, and what formats, fees, timing, and assistance apply. “You can export your data” is not enough if key documents, attachments, or structured details are difficult to obtain or reuse.
Test it: request a sample export and written transition terms before signing. Confirm how records and attachments can be accessed after termination.
5. Connections are promised but not demonstrated
Marketing may say a system “integrates” with a laboratory, pharmacy, hospital, clearinghouse, or other product, while the real connection transfers only some information or requires manual work. An interface should be evaluated for the data exchanged, reliability, errors, and workflow after receipt.
Test it: ask for a demonstration of the exact connection your practice needs, including a failed or incomplete transaction and how staff resolve it.
6. Downtime and recovery are treated as afterthoughts
Networks, devices, and services can become unavailable. An EMR evaluation should include how the organization will access critical information, document care, restore data, and reconcile temporary records after an outage.
Test it: request the vendor’s recovery commitments, responsibilities, escalation path, and support for the practice’s own downtime and emergency-mode procedures. HHS describes contingency planning and data recovery as part of the HIPAA Security Rule for regulated organizations.
7. Support and training are unclear
Without role-specific training and timely support, staff may develop inconsistent workarounds or struggle to use important functions. A product should come with clear expectations for onboarding, updates, support hours, and escalation—not just a login and a help-center link.
Test it: get support response times and training responsibilities in writing, and ask how new staff and major upgrades will be handled.
8. The system assumes every patient can use the same digital path
Online registration, portal messages, and digital forms can be helpful, but a practice should retain accessible alternatives for people who face language, disability, connectivity, or technology barriers. Digital convenience should not become an obstacle to receiving care or asking a question.
Test it: walk through the patient experience with accessibility and language needs in mind, and confirm how staff support patients who cannot complete a digital step.
Use a structured demo—not a feature tour
Before meeting vendors, write down the practice’s most important workflows and minimum requirements. Ask each vendor to demonstrate the same scenarios, such as a new-patient visit, medication reconciliation, an outside result, referral follow-up, and downtime. Score the results with the people who will use the system. ASTP/ONC’s Practice Transformation Toolkit includes resources for EHR implementation and evaluation; AHRQ’s Patient Safety Network discusses the relationship between usability and safety.
